Rai and Serela pick a different target or I will remove you from this game.
1: Why is this only directed at us and not PX/Yaersulf
2: I've just asked for people to convince me otherwise, particularly on the Serela wagon which is the secondary one. I am actively trying to look elsewhere at this point, aware that despite my efforts it seems not enough people think as badly of the circumstances [The lack of SENSE it makes; the situation he claimed in, and the fact he did so when pushing people for what he views as rolefishing] around Waffle's claim to lynch it.
If you want me to change my vote;
convince me. I heavily base my lynches off chance the person is scum v risk to Town. I do not
belive Waffle's claim however.
So you'll either need to convince me:
1: Waffle's claim is legitimate or at least is more likly to be legitimate than I think
2: Some other wagon has a higher chance of hitting scum.
I don't care if you're "tired" of hearing about the person I think is scum. I think they need to be lynched and currently a majority seems to agree!
4 votes is not a majority; Serela. As it stands a majority
disagree. Yeah meow was the biggest wagon and he was town too. He was also a newbie. I want to hear your other thoughts on other people.
The case on you (Serela) has been pretty scattered throughout. I just think you're being fake. I could try and put this together in a paragraph if you want but sb has done a decent job of doing so already.
My thoughts on Tom are that he is scummy for hyperlurking, bringing little to Town and the same reasons I brought up during Day 1 [Heavy OMGUS based voting, little~no effort to actually make cases; a few inconsistancies]
My opinion on Yaersulf has improved slightly during Day 2, but I still hold a weak scumread on him for Day 1 events that he's not fully shaken off.
I've pretty much changed my opinion from ED2 on Smartbomb/BBM based on events and posts since.
I have a slight suspicion of the Polaris/SB slot; that mostly comes from the Waffle case and the fact Waffle happily outed when asked by Polaris.
The case on Nuclear, from what I can see, seems to revolve heavily around "he said he targeted Daiya, but then said he forgot about Daiya". In this case, his action (as town) would've done nothing, and Daiya was lowposting in a game that's moving pretty damn quickly. I think this is a plausible explanation.
Are there Nuclear votes that actually delve into why his content is scummy? I don't mean "difficult to parse", I want someone to tell me what the scum motive for his actions are because he's definitely messy and I don't feel comfortable with him, but I don't see a reason to consider him crazy scum instead of crazy town right now.
My reason for voting Nuclear has more points than that; SB:
1: I think the circumstances around him claiming are incredibly suspicious; not just his claim of targeting Daiya. He claimed right after making a scumteam case that was largely rooted in people seeming to fish for Power Roles; when asked to fullclaim out of the blue by Polaris; at 2/7. This is very, very suspicious, and very very inconsistant with his Scumteam case. Surely Polaris outright asking for a fullclaim is far more 'Rolefishing' than anything in the exchange between me/BBM he says is rolefishing?
2: I think his 'case' on a Yaersulf/me/BBM scumteam is really desperate. Especially given Yaersulf/BBM are two people out of three I have actively tried to lynch and disagreed with. For this to be the case both my Mid Day 2 and Late Day 1 would have to be heavy bussing attempts. It indicates either he's just making up reads or flat-out not reading interactions.
3: There's the whole fact that targeting Daiya with his role N1 makes absolutely no sense. Not just from the 'he forgot he existed' perspective, but because pretty much no-one had expressed a particular townread on Daiya N1, and many were actually saying they'd vote him D2. This dosen't come across as a scumkill target; meaning:
a - Waffles is telling the truth and just chose perhaps the worst possible target to backup; and then forgot said pllayer existed D2
b - Waffles did target Daiya; but with some other role. This supports him claiming he knows Daiya is highly likly a PR. [By the way; why is he even giving out this info when he's accusing me/BBM of rolefishing?]
c - Is outright lying
As you can see, my scumread on Waffles comes from more than simply his targeting of Daiya. It's the combination of 1,2 and 3 which is making my 'fakeclaim' and 'scumclaim' alarms wail like mad.
