~Hakurei Shrine~ > Touhou Addict Recovery Center
Dissecting the Mysteries of Pseudo-Paradise
<< < (2/2)
Suspicious person:

--- Quote from: Mischief Maker on August 11, 2020, 04:02:35 AM ---are you saying that this is Alice’s current backstory

--- End quote ---
Not really, just drawing a bunch of parallels between Alice and the beautiful one. Nothing official here, just stuff that may or may not seem fitting

But speaking of backstories, Alice's various omake texts do not give her any, besides mentioning the fact that she was formerly a human ... which doesn't  contradict the theory at all, hmm


--- Quote from: Mischief Maker on August 11, 2020, 04:02:35 AM ---are you coming at this from the perspective of one last nod to the PC-98 canon?

--- End quote ---

Not exactly, the part about the Shrine maiden finding the beautiful one somewhat familiar is just similar to the PC-98 shout-out of sorts from PCB, so it might just be a nod towards the dialogue rather than the PC-98 era itself. Also the part about Makai is less substance and more speculation based on the presence of PC-98 influences from the time

At any rate, this here just happens to be a humble fan theory that may have quite a bit of stuff going for it. There's nothing official here, just one interpretation.
Hyouiibara:
Wait, isn't the person who try to hang itself a girl? And turned into Youkai?
And yes,maybe it's the girl in DiPP's jacket
Suspicious person:

--- Quote from: Hyouiibara on August 13, 2020, 02:07:05 AM ---Wait, isn't the person who try to hang itself a girl?

--- End quote ---
In my opinion, no, considering the following :
1/ The shrine maiden's notes mentionning that one of the honest men was a girl
2/ A beautiful blonde girl came out of the western-style building located in the forest
3/ The fact all of the honest men besides the beautiful one and the cowardly one / the one who was reborn were killed, while the cowardly one / the one who was reborn hanged themselves at the western-style building located in the forest :


Since 6 honest men were killed and 1 additional honest man hanging himself, you have 7 dead honest men out of the 8 of them, the last one being the beautiful one who only mysteriously "disappeared". Also considering the fact that the killing pierrot was mostly part of the group, it seems pretty logical to say that the last person to came out of the place they were staying at was the killer.

The beautiful one, aside from being the killer, should also be the only girl from the group cuz the person that came from the place they were at was a beautiful blonde girl (beautiful being the beautiful one's quality)


--- Quote from: Hyouiibara on August 13, 2020, 02:07:05 AM ---And turned into Youkai?

--- End quote ---
Honestly, it seems bizarre to me that if the one who was reborn would die by hanging themselves if they became a youkai. It seems more appropriate to me if they never managed to pull off the first suicide as they would note the fact that their feet didn't reach the ground in the second attempt.
Navigation
Message Index
Previous page

Go to full version